Serving classic comfort food & handcrafted cocktails

Right in the middle of main street and a short walk away from the ferry

Our casear wrap, filled with pesto, lettuce, onions, & tomatoes. Behind it a bed of french fries
On a white round plate, 6 clams filled with a blend of bacon, breading, & peppers. In the middle a lemon wedge
Overhead shot of two shrimp tacos, filled with oxaca cheese, tomatoes, lettuce. To the side is a cup of salsa verde & guacamole.
Picture showcasing our new hibiscus spritz

  • 115 Main St
    Port Jefferson, NY, 11777

    Located between Pindar and Tommy’s Place. Directly across from Ralph’s.

  • Mon & Tues: 4pm - 10pm

    Wed-Fri: 11:30am-10pm

    Sat: 11am-10pm

    Sun: 11am-12am


    LATE NIGHT HOURS:

    Fri & Sat: 10pm-3am

Pappardelle Bolognese
Hitmans BBQ Ribs
Black and Blue Burger
Bar Burger with Fries
Caesar Chicken Pesto wrap
Tuscan Chicken Sandwich with Fries
Caesar Salad with Chicken
Pulled Pork Nachos
Clams Casino
Bone-In Wings
Cucumber Salad and Burrata Salad behind an Apple Crisp-tini
Cucumber Salad
Pappardelle Bolognese
French Onion Soup
Linguini Vongole
Apple Marscapone Spread
Apple Whiskey Mule
Harvest Moon Margarita
Smoked Old Fashioned
Fig 75, Green Gatsby, Autumn Dove (Left to Right)

Happy Hour & Other Events

Happy Hour

Monday & Tuesday: 4PM - 6PM

Wednesday - Sunday: 2PM - 5PM

Restaurant Wide:

$3 Off Specialty Cocktails
$5 Domestic & Import
$6 Tap Beers
$7 Nütrls
$7 Surfsides
$7 House Liquor Drinks
$8 House Wine Glasses

Bar Seats Only:

$3 French Fries
$7 Mozzarella Sticks (8)
$8 Smash Cheeseburger
$9 Classic Crispy Chicken
$9 Pulled Pork Sandwich
$10 Hitman’s BBQ Ribs (4)
$10 Big Boy Pretzel
$10 Kung Pao Cauliflower
$10 Pulled Pork Nachos
$10 Boneless Wings
$10 Bone-In Wings

late Night

Friday & Saturday: 10PM - Last Call

Sunday: 9PM - Last Call

enjoy a Limited Food menu and
longer hours here at Prohibition!

Limited Menu:

$6 French Fries
$14 Mozzarella Sticks (8)
$7 Sweet Potato Fries
$8 Onion Rings
$17 Bone-In Wings
$17 Boneless Wings
$10 Bar Burger (with additions Available)

After Hours Pour

Sunday - Thursday: 9PM - Last Call

25% OFF all Drinks

“Went Here for my boyfriend’s birthday first time and it was awesome! The food was wow…super good/delicious. The service was great, and the decorations were perfect. Halloween vibes!! Everything was just right. We definitely recommend this spot!”

— Norel, on Google

What People Think

“Great Service! We were in a hurry and the bartender was pulling double duty as a waitress and got us out of there on time after the staff cooked a great lunch”

— Eric P, on Google

“Somehow always missed this spot when going down to port jeff. Checked it out and so glad we did! The food, drinks, and service were all excellent. Good vibe insides, fun music. Great menu options. Probably the best mozzarella sticks I’ve ever had. Can’t wait to come back!“

— mel s, on google

Frequently Asked Questions, FAQ

  • We take reservations for parties of 6 or more people.

  • During the week, our kitchen closes at 10pm & Sunday it closes at 9pm.
    Friday, Saturday, & Sunday we do offer a limited late-night menu after, which stops at 3am, 3am, & 12am respectively.

  • Yes, we do take-out orders. Give us a call and we can start yours now!

  • We don’t have a physical menu in store, but we offer plenty of options for your little ones. Plain Cheeseburgers, chicken nuggets, mac and cheese, and more! Just ask your server our other options.

  • We sure do! Every Saturday and Sunday from 11am - 3pm you can enjoy our brunch menu. We offer Avocado toast, chicken and waffles, and bottomless mimosas!

  • We do offer gluten free options, from salads, pasta, and gluten free buns for our burgers and chicken sandwiches.
    However, we are a small kitchen and do not have a gluten-free dedicated fryer.
    If there is an allergy in the party, it is highly recommended you let your server know.